Search
Confusion on charging taxes
by goodmorrow, Performer
- Created: March 21, 2010, 2:35 pm
- Updated: March 19, 2013, 10:45 am
Hello,
I'm actually still just in the research stage of wanting to start my own business and I'm sorting through all the links I've collected so far. I plan to mostly sell online. If I do sell in person, it would be at a fair or flea market. On this site, it says if you don't have an actual physical front, you don't need to collect tax. Yet many online businesses do. And NY requires getting a Certificate of Authority for it. Since I plan on occassionally selling in person, does that count as a physical front or does that only apply to actual stores that open and close daily? And if I choose to only sell online, do I still collect taxes if local residents purchase from me?
Thank you very much!
Comments have been locked for this thread.

Michael J. Fleming | Window Shopper | 3/15/2013 - 3:08 pm
the envelope in asserting what physical presence is. In some cases the US
Supreme Court has even ruled on these activities.
One common example would be the use of independent contractors. They are not
your employees and may not even represent just you or your products but if
they are soliciting for you then they are creating nexus for you. The Supreme
Court ruled on this in 1960 in the Scripto Case and again in 1987 with the
Tyler Pipe Case.
Having employees visit a client could be a nexus creating activity, attending
a trade show could be a nexus creating activity, using a drop shipper could
be a nexus creating activity. The list goes on and on and is different from
state to state.
While nexus may sound confusing, it is less so the more you work with it. If
anyone has a specific question I would be more than happy to share how a
specific state may or may not look at the situation.
Michael J. Fleming | Window Shopper | 3/15/2013 - 2:53 pm
In most of the answers to the sales tax questions the line, "If your business
has a physical presence in a state, such as a store, office or warehouse" is
being overused which can lead to false impressions.
Physical presence is required for sales tax, but it includes so much more
than the real property this statement list. For example if you are present in
a state that is a physical presence. I do not know of any states that would
not assert this is a nexus creating activity.
Sales tax is based on your ship to address so any sales you are selling in NY
would be subject to sales tax, in addition to your flea market sales.
goodmorrow | Performer | 3/21/2010 - 2:35 pm
NicoleD | Former Moderator | 3/21/2010 - 2:35 pm
phanio | Contributor | 3/21/2010 - 2:35 pm
CutCompCosts | Contributor | 3/21/2010 - 2:35 pm
Join The Discussion
You must be logged in to join the discussion. If you already have an SBA Community account, Log In to join the discussion.
New users, Register for a new account and join the conversation today!